book review: The Mars Room by Rachel Kushner


THE MARS ROOM by Rachel Kushner
Scribner, 2018

I’m not sure if I’m going to manage the entire Man Booker longlist this year – stay tuned to find out – but I’m prioritizing the books that I’m the most excited about, as well as the books that I’m having the easiest time getting my hands on. The Mars Room fell into the latter category. But this is exactly what I love about literary prizes, because I never would have picked this book up ordinarily, and I ended up loving it.

The Mars Room is an incisive and unsentimental look at the US prison system, through the eyes of Romy, a young mother who finds herself at the beginning of two life sentences. Kushner then explores this narrative from numerous vantage points – the socioeconomic factors that lead to incarceration; the brutal realities of prison life; what it means on a psychological level to be confronted with a life sentence.

While I felt Kushner’s political agenda in writing this book was clear, it was actually rendered much more subtly than I had been expecting, which I appreciated. Romy was a thoroughly convincing protagonist, and it never felt like she had an unrealistic understanding of the political structures at play in her own story; she simply relayed her own reality to the reader, and Kushner was able to expertly tie that into the larger context. I think I’d describe this book as first and foremost a novel about humanity. These characters have all done terrible things, and Kushner makes no effort to excuse or glorify or sensationalize any of it. But she still treats each of their stories with compassion, and is interested in the question of when a person stops being a victim (of abuse, of poverty, of systemic violence) and is able to be classified as a villain.

The interplay between the natural and the artificial is another element that I found intriguing, and I thought it came together beautifully in the novel’s conclusion, but I did think the execution of this element could have been stronger on the whole. I guess this ties into my biggest criticism of this book, which is that Kushner isn’t quite able to justify the chorus of voices in which her novel is narrated. Alongside Romy, we have chapters narrated by other inmates, by one of Romy’s teachers who works in the prison, by the man who used to stalk Romy (which led to the altercation which landed her in prison). We also have excerpts from the diaries of Ted Kaczynski, more commonly known as the Unabomber, which is the element that eludes me the most when I think about how this novel is structured. I think this may have been an attempt to draw parallels to Kaczynski’s self-imposed primitive lifestyle and the manufactured and inhumane law and order of the prison system, but Kushner seems to expect her reader to do most of the legwork with this comparison, scattering Kaczynski’s diary entries throughout the narrative in a haphazard fashion. The perspective from an unrelated male inmate in a separate prison likewise struck me as superfluous, or else not integrated into the narrative in a way that ever justifies its inclusion.

But mostly I found this to be a very intelligent and quietly thought-provoking read, and though it isn’t exactly a pretty book, I wouldn’t describe it as gratuitous, either. Kushner elucidates harsh realities and it results in a dismal and disturbing narrative at times, but it’s never without compassion for the individuals whose stories she’s telling.

More of my Man Booker 2018 reviews:

From a Low and Quiet Sea | The Water Cure

29 thoughts on “book review: The Mars Room by Rachel Kushner

  1. Interesting. I was not a fan of the ending and of the general inclusion of both Thoreau and the Unabomber. Except for that I did love the chorus of voices and I even came around to most of the male perspectives upon reflection.
    But I agree on the whole. It is wonderfully done overall and Romy is a great protagonist.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Ugh this is what I mean about not being happy with this review. I left so much out. So, I’m conflicted about the ending. I thought on the whole it was rather rushed, but the last few pages I did find beautiful. And I loved Romy’s musings about nature and I understood how Kushner wanted that to tie into the larger narrative, but I don’t think it was a total success because this theme was never really examined to its full potential. So, I loved the note that it ended on, but wished it had earned its impact a bit more? I really really don’t think the Thoreau/Unabomber thing was executed well at all. And the voice that I’m still the most unconvinced by is Doc’s. Some of the others make sense to me and some don’t, but Doc’s I just really don’t get the point of. Off to read your review.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Ugh I got detained by work on my way to reading your review. Going now. But YES, exactly?? Even if Betty had been a more central character, I don’t think Doc is really a counterpoint to her character, as you said. Gordon and the stalker I get even if I don’t think they’re strictly necessary, but Doc just baffles me.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Yes! Also! Since the majority of his section was about masturbation… I almost felt like Kushner was buying into the ‘female masturbation is a taboo subject’ myth by giving that narrative to a man? I just found that odd.

        Liked by 1 person

    • I’m actually not big on the prison setting either, I think it’s because I hated Orange is the New Black so much and I assume all prison-set things are going to be like that? So, my reaction to this came as a huge surprise. And thank you!

      Liked by 1 person

      • I hated OitNB too, and I recently read The Captives and Fellside, both set in prison, which I didn’t get on with either! I suppose there will always be that one book that will change my opinion though! 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

      • Oh yay I’m glad I’m not alone with the OITNB hate. That show was awful. Making a note to avoid both of those books! But yes, I’d definitely recommend The Mars Room if you ever do feel like giving prison stories another chance.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. […] 7. The Mars Room by Rachel Kushner** shortlisted Quick summary: A young mother Romy receives two life sentences for murdering her stalker, and we follow her and other inmates in a woman’s prison as they grapple with the difficult realities of their new life. Quick review: Both nuanced and thorough, The Mars Room went above and beyond what I was expecting from its premise, but unfortunately a handful of POV characters end up being extraneous and Kushner is never able to justify their inclusion or integrate their voices into the narrative in a cohesive way. Full review HERE ★★★★☆ […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s