book review: A Natural by Ross Raisin



A NATURAL by Ross Raisin
Random House, 2017


The thing that should not be underestimated as you read through my thoughts on A Natural is just how much I hate sports – which probably raises the question of why I decided a book about football/soccer to begin with, to which I can answer: if I had understood the extent to which this book is about football/soccer, I probably would not have picked in up in the first place. Instead I’d seen it billed as a coming-of-age novel about a gay footballer, and I suppose I thought the football/soccer would be mostly backdrop. Reader, it was not backdrop.

There’s a reason this book is 400 pages, and it’s because Ross Raisin details just about every single match, every single inner working of this low-level soccer club, with unerring precision. And for the first half of the book, it was frankly driving me mad. But then in the second half of the novel, when we start to dive into the meat of the story – our protagonist Tom beginning a relationship with the club’s groundskeeper – I found that my frustration with Raisin’s narrative choices was beginning to abate. Yes, I still found the soccer talk endlessly tedious, but the criticisms that I’d had (that soccer was the foreground, Tom’s story was the background, how does this make for a compelling narrative at all, why hadn’t an editor come at this manuscript with a machete) started to mostly* fly out the window, because it’s impossible to deny how well-crafted this book is. It’s a slow burn in every sense of the phrase: it’s a slow-paced story, and (unless you’re riveted by soccer) it withholds its rewards until you get to the end.

*I did have another criticism that never fully faded, though I began to understand it more in the second half: why certain chapters were given to the perspective of a married couple, one of Tom’s fellow footballers, Chris, and his wife Leah. Their story does dovetail with the central narrative and I do understand the decision to include their point of view, but I’m not convinced that we needed as much detail here as we got.

I know I’m doing a pretty poor job of selling this or explaining my 4 star rating (hang in there!), but the thing is, I’m not sure that this is a book I’d widely recommend. It takes patience and perseverance and if I were in the habit of DNFing I probably would have called it quits at the halfway mark. But if this sounds at all like a story you’re willing to commit to, it gets really, really good. Raisin navigates the homophobic world of professional sport with a deft hand, meditating with perception on themes of performative masculinity, shame, and the tension between the inner and outer selves. I think Raisin is a tremendously gifted writer, and the way he renders the relationship between Tom and Liam is so palpably fragile that it’s almost painful to read at times.  So while this book wasn’t perfectly targeted to my preferences as a reader, I do think it’s a gem of a book that I’m glad to have read… and ultimately to have stuck with.

You can pick up a copy of A Natural here on Book Depository.

17 thoughts on “book review: A Natural by Ross Raisin

  1. I felt very similarly about A Natural (though I liked Leah’s chapters)! I read it a couple of years ago now and, while it’s not a novel I’d rush to read again, I got a lot out of it. Have you read either of Raisin’s other novels? I liked both, but not sure if they’ve made it to the US.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes absolutely! On the one hand it was undeniably brilliant and I’m so glad to have read it but on the other hand, so. much. soccer. I think Leah’s chapters added more than Chris’s did, and though I definitely understood the inclusion of both of their POVs I just kept wishing we could stay on Tom, but I think that’s a personal preference… it’s hard to argue that this book isn’t structured well.

      And no, I haven’t! Apparently God’s Own Country was published here as Out Backward, and it looks like Harper published Waterline as well – I’ll definitely keep an eye out. Any preference between the two?

      Liked by 1 person

      • Oh, tricky – they’re very different books, while sharing Raisin’s preoccupation with men who are social outcasts for one reason or another. I found Waterline more moving and memorable, but God’s Own Country is pacier, more gripping and has a more interesting voice. Depends what you prefer!

        Liked by 1 person

      • Oh interesting – since A Natural was the slowest of all slow burns at this point I’m probably inclined to reach for the pacier one next, but they both sound good! I’m definitely interested in picking up both at some point. He’s a great writer!

        Liked by 1 person

    • Right?? My conflict exactly… my gut tells me that you would find this tedious because god there is SO MUCH FOOTBALL but ugh, it’s brilliant! It’s definitely a Project Book, which I hadn’t been expecting from the ‘queer coming of age novel’ summary, but it took me about a month to read and I only really started getting into it a week ago once the football talk had died down a bit and the story got going.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. He does write really beautifully, but yes, I had a tough time figuring out who to sell this to for precisely that reason: how do you balance out the football with the examination of masculinity and gender?! He’s probably worth a go, though…

    Liked by 1 person

    • It’s SO tricky because the intersection of football enthusiasts and people riveted by thorough explorations of toxic masculinity is… probably not the most happening niche in the world. But I hope the five people this appeals to find this book because it is so brilliant.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. […] A Natural by Ross Raisin: I don’t know much about this other than that it features a gay protagonist who plays football (soccer), and that a friend of mine loved it and recommended it to me very highly.  I included it on my last 5 star predictions post that I made way earlier this year, so I do want to get to this one sooner rather than later.  EDIT: ★★★★☆ | review […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s